GET CALLS 
- September 12, 2025
Affordable Care Act (ACA) insurance has created significant opportunities for agents and brokers across the United States. With millions of consumers needing health coverage, the key to success isn’t simply finding leads—it’s finding high-quality, high-intent leads who are ready to enroll. In today’s competitive market, standing out requires a blend of smart marketing, compliance, and relationship-building.
This blog breaks down proven strategies that help agents and agencies generate ACA insurance leads that convert. By focusing on quality over quantity, you can reduce wasted effort, increase enrollments, and grow your book of business sustainably.
Before launching any lead generation campaign, it’s crucial to understand the ACA landscape. Who are your ideal prospects? Are you focusing on individuals who qualify for subsidies, small business owners seeking group plans, or families needing pediatric coverage? By defining your target market, you can tailor your outreach, messaging, and filters for better results.
Tip: Create buyer personas including income levels, age brackets, household size, and preferred communication channels to ensure each campaign speaks directly to your audience.
Today’s consumers start their insurance journey online. Make sure your website, landing pages, and social profiles are optimized for ACA-related keywords and topics. Publish blog posts, guides, and FAQs answering common ACA questions. The more educational and transparent your content is, the more trust you’ll build with prospective clients.
Implement clear calls-to-action (CTAs) like “Get a Free ACA Quote” or “Check Your Subsidy Eligibility.” These CTAs convert website visitors into actionable leads.
Paid search ads on Google and Bing and targeted social ads on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn allow you to reach consumers actively searching for ACA plans. Use geo-targeting, demographic filters, and intent-based keywords to drive only the most relevant traffic.
Make sure your ad copy emphasizes compliance and consumer benefits: affordable premiums, subsidy assistance, and expert guidance through enrollment. Testing different creatives and landing pages can also improve your click-through and conversion rates.
Sometimes the fastest way to scale is to work with specialized ACA lead providers who deliver pre-qualified, TCPA-compliant leads in real time. These partners can filter by household income, subsidy eligibility, and location to ensure you’re speaking with prospects who match your ideal client profile.
Look for providers who offer:
Leads that come to you—rather than you chasing them—convert at much higher rates. Warm transfers, where the consumer is screened before being connected to you, ensure you’re speaking with someone who’s ready to enroll. Live inbound calls take it a step further: these are people dialing your number for help right now.
While these leads cost more upfront, the improved conversion rates and faster sales cycles often justify the investment.
No matter how great your leads are, slow follow-up kills conversions. Have a system to respond immediately to inquiries and missed calls. Use a CRM to automate reminders, track conversations, and segment leads by stage in the buying process.
When you follow up, lead with value: explain subsidy options, enrollment deadlines, and how your services make the ACA process easier. Seniors and families alike appreciate agents who are responsive and knowledgeable.
ACA plans can be complex, with varying coverage levels, provider networks, and subsidy rules. Position yourself as an educator rather than just a salesperson. Offer free webinars, short explainer videos, or downloadable guides covering “How to Choose an ACA Plan” or “How to Estimate Your Subsidy.”
This builds trust and credibility while reducing the time you spend answering the same questions over and over.
The best lead generation strategies are data-driven. Monitor cost per lead, cost per acquisition, and retention rates for each channel. Run A/B tests on ad copy, landing page designs, and call scripts to see what resonates most with your audience.
Use dashboards or analytics tools to identify your top-performing sources and double down on them. Small tweaks can lead to big improvements over time.
Compliance protects your license and reputation. Make sure your marketing materials are approved where required, your disclosures are clear, and your data collection methods comply with TCPA, CMS, and HIPAA regulations. Working with compliant partners ensures your leads won’t create legal or ethical headaches down the road.
High-quality ACA insurance leads are the foundation of a thriving health insurance business. By understanding your ideal prospect, optimizing your online presence, using targeted advertising, partnering with reputable lead providers, leveraging warm transfers, and following up quickly, you can build a pipeline of motivated consumers who need your help navigating ACA coverage.
In a crowded marketplace, agents who focus on delivering value, staying compliant, and continually refining their strategies will consistently outperform the competition. Start implementing these proven techniques today, and watch your ACA enrollments grow.